Mitigating the effect of the population model uncertainty on the strong lensing Bayes factor using nonparametric methods
利用非参数方法减轻群体模型不确定性对强透镜贝叶斯因子的影响
Strong lensing of gravitational waves can produce several detectable images as repeated events in the upcoming observing runs, which can be detected with the posterior overlap analysis (Bayes factor). The choice of the binary black hole population plays an important role in the analysis as two gravitational-wave events could be similar either because of lensing or astrophysical coincidence. In this study, we investigate the biases induced by different population models on the Bayes factor. We build up a mock catalog of gravitational-wave events following a benchmark population and reconstruct it using both nonparametric and parametric methods. Using these reconstructions, we compute the Bayes factor for lensed pair events by utilizing both models and compare the results with a benchmark model. We show that the use of a nonparametric population model gives a smaller bias than parametric population models. Therefore, our study demonstrates the importance of choosing a sufficiently agnostic population model for strong lensing analyses.
展开 ▾首次系统对比参数与非参数人群模型在强透镜分析中的偏差,证明使用非参数(H)DPGMM模型可有效缓解因模型假设错误导致的贝叶斯因子偏差,挑战了传统使用均匀先验的保守性认知。
引力波强透镜探测依赖于贝叶斯因子来区分真实透镜事例与天体物理偶然性。后验重叠分析 Haris+ 2018 常被用于此,但其结果受到黑洞双星群体模型选择的强烈影响。此前研究或采用特定参数模型如 PowerLaw+Peak 模型 Abbott+ 2023c,或采用均匀模型 Diego+ 2021,但这些选择可能引入偏差。本研究承接这些工作,通过模拟数据系统评估了错误模型的影响,并展示了非参数模型 Rinaldi+ 2022 的优势。展望未来,为了在真实数据中可靠地确认首例强透镜事件,应优先采用灵活的非参数模型来重建观测群体,并将其作为预筛选工具,以配合计算成本更高的联合参数估计方法 Lo+ 2023 进行最终确认,共同推动引力波宇宙学与基础物理的精确检验。
预印本 2023-08-23 · 刊出 2025-03-04 · 收录 2026-10-12