Can binary-black-hole-merger gravitational-wave data constrain corrections to Bekenstein-Hawking entropy?
双黑洞并合引力波数据能否约束贝肯斯坦-霍金熵的修正?
We examine possible additive corrections to the Bekenstein-Hawking (BH) entropy of black holes due to very general classical and quantal modifications of general relativity. In general, black-hole entropy is subject to the generalized second law of thermodynamics. For the case of binary-black-hole coalescence, the difference in corrections to the inspiral and remnant black-hole entropies is shown, within this law, to be bounded by the difference in the corresponding BH entropies. This latter difference has been measured by several groups attempting to validate Hawking's area theorem on black-hole horizons, by analyzing gravitational-wave data from possible binary-black-hole mergers. The former difference---that between corrections to remnant and inspiral black-hole entropies beyond the BH entropy, is thus constrained by a bound measured from observational data. We examine the implications of this constraint for general binary-black-hole coalescence. If calculated entropy corrections follow the essential pattern of BH entropies dictated by the Hawking area theorem, consistency with the observational bound is shown to be guaranteed. If they do not, these corrections are then nontrivially constrained by the observational bound.
展开 ▾模型无关地推导出GSL对熵修正的约束不等式,并利用已观测的BBH并合事件GW150914等数据验证的面积定理结果,区分出两类修正:若修正使熵减少则自动一致,若增加则受到观测限制,甚至能区分量子引力修正的符号。
黑洞熵的概念由Bekenstein提出Bekenstein 1973,并由Hawking面积定理Hawking 1971支撑,进而发展为广义第二定律(GSL)。作者前期工作Majumdar 2024在圈量子引力中考察了对数熵修正,发现其与GW数据约束的一致性依赖于修正符号。本文进一步推广至任意加性修正,利用多个研究组(如Pooh-Kolb+ 2020)对GW数据分析得出的面积定理正面验证结果,得到对修正的一般性约束:若修正不遵循面积定理的单调性,则其大小受观测限制。这一方法为今后利用更高精度GW数据检验修正引力理论(如Lovelock引力、Horndeski理论等)以及区分不同量子引力候选方案提供了唯象学途径。
预印本 2024-08-25 · 刊出 2025-03-12 · 收录 2026-10-13