Accounting for the known unknowns: A parametric framework to incorporate systematic waveform errors in gravitational-wave parameter estimation
考虑已知的未知:引力波参数估计中纳入波形系统误差的参数化框架
The parameter estimation (PE) for gravitational wave (GW) merger events relies on a waveform model calibrated using numerical simulations. Within the Bayesian framework, this waveform model represents the GW signal produced during the merger and is crucial for estimating the likelihood function. However, these waveform models may possess systematic errors that can differ across the parameter space. Addressing these errors in the current data analysis pipeline is an active area of research. We introduce parametrizations for the uncertainties in the amplitude and phase of the reference waveform model. When the error budget in the amplitude and phase of the waveform model, as a function of frequency, is known, it can be used as a prior distribution in the Bayesian framework. We also show that conservative priors can be used to quantify uncertainties in waveform modeling without any knowledge of waveform uncertainty error budgets. Through zero-noise injections and PE recoveries, we demonstrate that even 1%--2% of errors in relative phase to the actual waveform model, for a GW150914-like signal and advanced LIGO detector sensitivity, can introduce biases in the recovered parameters. These biases can be corrected when we account for waveform uncertainties within the PE framework. By analyzing a series of simulated signals from mergers with precessing orbits and recovering them using a nonspinning waveform model, we demonstrate that we can reduce the ratio of systematic errors to statistical errors. This approach allows us to address scenarios where specific physical effects are missing in waveform modeling. The code that implements our parametrization for performing PE is available as a Python package ``pycbc_wferrors_plugin'', compatible with the PyCBC open source GW analysis library.
展开 ▾首次将波形系统误差显式参数化为可融入贝叶斯推断的三次样条函数,并展示了在无先验误差预算时仍可纠正有偏参数;仅1%的相对相位误差即可导致GW150914类信号的明显偏差,而该方法可有效恢复注入的误差特征,并用于吸收缺失物理(如旋进)带来的系统效应。
既往缓解波形系统误差的方法包括组合不同波形模型的后验样本 Abbott+ 2023 或利用超参数进行模型选择 Ashton+ 2022,但这些方法无法处理所有模型共有的系统性偏差。基于数值相对论校准误差的高斯过程回归模型 Moore+ 2014 虽可提供概率波形,但仍有局限性。本研究将频率依赖的振幅和相位误差直接参数化为三次样条,并纳入贝叶斯参数估计,相较于线性信号近似下的Fisher矩阵方法,在较大波形偏离(如相对相位误差1%)时仍可纠正偏差 Pürrer+ 2020。该方法亦被展示可降低因遗漏物理效应(如自旋旋进)导致的系统误差与统计误差之比 Dhani+ 2024。展望未来,波形模型开发者应提供频率依赖的误差包络作为先验,并向更灵活的节点设置及非振荡性误差结构拓展。
预印本 2025-02-24 · 刊出 2025-11-24 · 收录 2026-10-12