Reducing systematic uncertainties in gravitational-wave population analyses by increasing the detection threshold
通过提高探测阈值减小引力波群体分析中的系统误差
From catalogs of gravitational-wave transients, the population-level properties of their sources and the formation channels of merging compact binaries can be constrained. However, astrophysical conclusions can be biased by misspecification or misestimation of the population likelihood. Despite detection thresholds on the false-alarm rate (FAR) or signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), the current catalog is likely contaminated by noise transients. Further, computing the population likelihood becomes less accurate as the catalog grows. Current methods to address these challenges often scale poorly with the number of events and potentially become infeasible for future catalogs. Here, we evaluate a simple remedy: increasing the significance threshold for including events in population analyses. To determine the efficacy of this approach, we analyze simulated catalogs of up to 1600 gravitational-wave signals from black-hole mergers using full Bayesian parameter estimation with current detector sensitivities. We show that the growth in statistical uncertainty about the black-hole population, as we analyze fewer events but with higher SNR, depends on the source parameters of interest. When the SNR threshold is raised from 11 to 15---reducing our catalog size by two--thirds---we find that statistical uncertainties on the mass distribution only grow by a few 10% and constraints on the spin distribution are essentially unchanged; meanwhile, uncertainties on the high-redshift cosmic merger rate more than double. Simultaneously, numerical uncertainty in the estimate of the population likelihood more than halves, allowing us to ensure unbiased inference without additional computational expense. Our results demonstrate that focusing on higher-significance events is an effective way to facilitate robust astrophysical inference with growing gravitational-wave catalogs.
展开 ▾提出通过提升SNR阈值来直接清洗样本并降低似然估计的数值方差,无需增加计算资源;模拟显示将SNR阈值从11提高到15(样本数减少三分之二),质量分布统计误差仅增约60%,自旋分布约束几乎不变,而似然估计方差减半以上。
此前Gaebel+ 2019等通过联合噪声建模处理系统误差,Essick+ 2024和Haster+ 2020利用Fisher矩阵分析了不同源参数的信息贡献,但Fisher近似在高维参数空间可能不准确。Talbot+ 2023指出群体似然的蒙特卡洛方差随样本数快速增长,威胁推断的无偏性。本文在全参数估计模拟下证明,适度提高SNR阈值(如从11到15)既能有效控制上述方差,又能保持对质量、自旋分布的良好约束,仅红移演化率误差显著增大。展望未来,随着Gupta+ 2024等下一代探测器产生海量事件,该方法可作为一种简单补充手段降低计算负担和噪声污染,但其效果需在更灵活的群体模型和真实搜索背景下进一步验证。
预印本 2025-10-07 · 刊出 2026-05-14 · 收录 2026-10-12