Interpreting the diversity of afterglow emission from radio-detected tidal disruption events with instantaneous and delayed outflows
用瞬时与延迟外流解释射电探测潮汐瓦解事件余辉的多样性
Tidal disruption events (TDEs) occur when a star is gravitationally disrupted by the tidal field of a supermassive black hole during a close encounter. Radio emission has recently been detected in TDEs and is commonly attributed to synchrotron radiation from both wind and jetted outflows. However, several TDEs exhibit bright radio flares at late times, which cannot be easily explained if the wind is launched promptly after the stellar disruption. The radio light curves of TDEs with delayed radio flares are modeled using three scenarios: an instantaneous wind, a delayed wind, and a delayed relativistic jet. We show that the instantaneous wind model struggles to reproduce delayed radio flare events, indicating the necessity of an additional delayed outflow component. In contrast, the delayed wind model provides a consistent explanation for the observed radio phenomenology, successfully reproducing events both with and without delayed radio flares. For some delayed radio flare events (e.g., ASASSN-15oi and AT 2019dsg), both the delayed wind and delayed jet models can reproduce the observed radio light curves, making it challenging to distinguish between these scenarios based on radio data alone. To break this degeneracy, we present calculations of detailed multiwavelength spectra from radio to x-ray and very-high-energy gamma-ray bands, including both synchrotron and inverse-Compton processes. Within this framework, the delayed jet model produces x-ray and optical emission detectable at typical TDE distances, in contrast to wind-driven scenarios. Our results highlight how multiwavelength campaigns offer effective means to distinguish between possible outflow mechanisms. We apply our model to AT 2025aarm, which is one of the closest TDEs that has been observed, and show the importance of x-ray observations.
展开 ▾系统比较三种外流情景并覆盖 9 个事件:瞬时风无法解释延迟射电耀发,而延迟风与延迟喷流常给出同样好的射电拟合;作者据此计算从射电到 X 射线、TeV 的同步辐射与 SSC 谱,指出延迟喷流伴随的 X 射线/光学余辉可被 Chandra 与 Rubin 探测,是打破简并的关键,并将其应用于最近的近距事件 AT 2025aarm。
自 Rees 1988 确立潮汐瓦解事件的经典图像以来,射电波段成为探测 TDE 外流(喷流与风)的关键窗口,高光度射电暂现源被归为相对论喷流,较暗的一类则归为亚相对论风。近年来 ASASSN-15oi、AT 2019dsg、AT 2018hyz 等事件在光学发现后约 10^8 s 才出现射电耀发,Horesh+ 2021 与 Cendes+ 2024 的系统观测表明这类晚期射电辐射在光学选择的 TDE 中相当普遍,但单一瞬时外流难以解释。围绕其起源,学界提出了延迟外流、CNM 密度跃变、离轴/双成分喷流以及延迟喷流被盘风扼制等多种解释(如 Matsumoto+ 2024、Sato+ 2024、Teboul+ 2023)。本文在统一的余辉框架下比较瞬时风、延迟风与延迟喷流三种情景,指出射电数据本身常无法区分风与喷流,必须借助 X 射线、光学与高频射电的联合观测来打破简并。随着 Rubin、SKAO、CTAO 等新一代设施投入运行,对延迟外流实施高节奏多波段追踪,将成为约束 TDE 吸积与外流机制、并可能修正喷流 TDE 发生率估计的主要途径。
预印本 2025-12-29 · 刊出 2026-11-03 · 收录 2026-11-15